Anna Maria, FL Subdivisions & Condo Buildings

Anna Maria's 21 subdivisions and condo buildings sit on a barrier island where inventory turns over slowly and every community trades on proximity to the beach. Shore Acres stands out as the largest by listing count, backed by a solid mix of single-family homes and vacant lots. Anna Maria Beach is another high-volume community, offering both single-family homes and condos, while Bimini Bay Estates and Luana Isles round out the active segment with steady single-family activity. There's no age-restricted 55+ product here; this is a family and second-home market through and through. You'll find a clear split between long-established neighborhoods like Laguna Maria, Tuttle Terrace and Wells Terrace, where resales dominate and turnover is rare, and newer or rebuilt communities such as Lake La Vista, Island Cedars and Villa Rosa, which bring new construction into a tightly built island footprint. Smaller pockets like Bay Harbor, Gulf View and Lacios add variety without changing the island's overall character. Buyers here are typically cash-ready, upper-budget purchasers targeting a coastal primary residence, vacation retreat, or investment property, and pricing across these subdivisions reflects that reality.

–

Anna Maria Beach

There are currently 23 single-family homes from $1,250,000 to $5,895,000 and 1 condo at $649,000 for sale.

Single FamilyCondoTownhouseLandMulti-UnitNew Construction
$445,000–$5,350,000
Median $1,447,500
24 for sale

Bay Harbor

2 homes sold in the past year ranging from $2,250,000 to $7,850,000.

Single FamilyLand
$2,250,000–$7,850,000
Median $5,050,000

Bimini Bay Colony Club

There are currently 2 single-family homes from $1,525,000 to $1,595,000 and 1 multi-unit property at $1,750,000 for sale.

Single FamilyMulti-Unit
$1,040,000–$1,945,000
Median $1,750,000
3 for sale

Bimini Bay Estates

There are currently 9 single-family homes from $1,500,000 to $8,000,000 for sale.

Single FamilyLandNew Construction
$1,800,000–$5,550,000
Median $5,500,000
9 for sale

Bluewater Palms

1 home sold in the past year at $7,750,000.

Single FamilyLand
$7,750,000

Coconut Bayou

There is currently 1 single-family home at $2,595,000 for sale.

Single FamilyNew Construction
$2,550,000–$2,770,000
Median $2,660,000
1 for sale

Diamond Beach

There are currently no homes for sale in Diamond Beach.

Single FamilyLand

Gulf View

3 homes sold in the past year ranging from $1,400,000 to $3,300,000.

Single FamilyLand
$1,400,000–$3,300,000
Median $1,550,000

Island Cedars

There are currently 2 single-family homes from $1,847,000 to $1,895,000 for sale.

Single FamilyMulti-UnitNew Construction
$2,165,000–$2,200,000
Median $2,182,500
2 for sale

Lacios

There are currently 2 single-family homes from $2,499,900 to $4,995,000 for sale.

Single FamilyLand
$2,050,000–$2,825,000
Median $2,137,500
2 for sale

Laguna Maria

2 homes sold in the past year ranging from $840,000 to $3,100,000.

Single FamilyLand
$840,000–$3,100,000
Median $1,970,000

Lake La Vista

There are currently 4 single-family homes from $1,799,900 to $6,995,000 for sale.

Single FamilyLandNew Construction
$950,000–$2,300,000
Median $1,705,000
4 for sale

Lardas

2 homes sold in the past year ranging from $1,925,000 to $2,395,000.

Single Family
$1,925,000–$2,395,000
Median $2,160,000

Luana Isles

There are currently 5 single-family homes from $1,175,000 to $2,900,000 and 2 land listings from $1,175,000 to $2,000,000 for sale.

Single FamilyLandNew Construction
$975,000–$4,250,000
Median $1,499,000
7 for sale

Shore Acres

There are currently 13 single-family homes from $825,000 to $8,250,000 and 1 land listing at $2,550,000 for sale.

Single FamilyLandMulti-UnitNew Construction
$875,000–$5,575,000
Median $1,750,000
14 for sale

The Arroyo

1 home sold in the past year at $1,750,000.

Single FamilyLand
$1,750,000

Tuttle Terrace

1 home sold in the past year at $1,200,000.

Single FamilyLand
$1,200,000

Villa Rosa

There is currently 1 single-family home at $7,295,000 for sale.

Single FamilyLandNew Construction
1 for sale

Wells

There are currently 4 land listings from $1,595,000 to $4,300,000 for sale.

Single FamilyLand
$1,267,500
4 for sale

Wells Bay Harbor

There are currently 6 single-family homes from $2,150,000 to $8,995,000 for sale.

Single FamilyLandMulti-UnitNew Construction
$850,000–$3,600,000
Median $3,050,000
6 for sale

Wells Terrace

1 home sold in the past year at $1,200,000.

Single FamilyLand
$1,200,000
See all homes for sale in Anna Maria
Sold Homes

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.