Carthage, IL Homes for Sale & Real Estate

Carthage, Illinois, is a small, historic city in Hancock County, serving as the county seat with a population of around 2,500. Known for its rich history, Carthage was a significant location during the mid-19th century, particularly as the site where Mormon leader Joseph Smith was killed in 1844 at the Carthage Jail, now a historic site and museum. The city features a charming downtown with well-preserved buildings, including the Hancock County Courthouse, and hosts community events like the annual Carthage Christmas Open House. Surrounded by fertile farmland, Carthage maintains a close-knit, agricultural community vibe while offering a glimpse into Illinois' historical past.

Housing Market Report

Check out the hottest and the coldest price ranges in Carthage.

Active 55+ Communities

Live your life fully in a Carthage community built for adults 55 and older.

Compare Cities

See how prices, $/ft2, and taxes in Carthage stack up to other cities.

Marco Amidei

Real Estate Agent

Have questions? Looking to buy or sell? (888) 326-2726

Email Me

Real Estate News

October 10, 2026

New Homes with Master Bedrooms on the 1st Floor in Carthage: October 3rd to October 9th

Carthage had only 1 new home for sale with a master bedroom on the first floor during the month…

October 9, 2026

New Homes For Sale This Week in Carthage: October 2nd to October 8th

Carthage had only 1 new home for sale during the week of Friday, October 2 to Thursday, October 8, including…

October 3, 2026

New Homes with Master Bedrooms on the 1st Floor in Carthage: September 26th to October 2nd

Carthage had only 1 new home for sale with a master bedroom on the first floor during the month…

September 29, 2026

Homes Just Sold in Carthage: September 22nd to September 28th

Carthage had only 1 sale during the week of Tuesday, September 22 to Monday, September 28, including and it was…

September 5, 2026

New Homes with Master Bedrooms on the 1st Floor in Carthage: August 29th to September 4th

Carthage had only 1 new home for sale with a master bedroom on the first floor during the month…

View More Carthage News

Real Estate News

View More Carthage News

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.