Top 10 Most Expensive Streets in Payson, AZ

The following are the Top 10 most expensive streets in Payson. The average price for homes on these streets range from $1,650,000 to $3,350,000.

Spring is coming

Spring into action! The spring market has arrived!

Now is a great time to sell your home while demand is highest and competition is still low! We can offer you tips on how to make your home stand out above the rest and increase your odds for a more successful sale.

Doug Ferguson

Call Doug Today! (404) 458-1672

1. Big Forest Way

Big Forest Way is the 1st most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built in 2003, with an average sale price of $3,350,000.

Average Price: $3,350,000
View All Recent Sales divider

2. Morning Glory Circle

Morning Glory Circle is the 2nd most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes and land built in 2026, with an average sale price of $2,600,000. It is home to the Chaparral Pines subdivision.

Average Price: $2,600,000
View All Recent Sales divider

3. Shady Glade

Shady Glade is the 3rd most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built in 2006, with an average sale price of $2,098,000.

Average Price: $2,098,000
View All Recent Sales divider

4. Starview Drive

Starview Drive is the 4th most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built in 2018, with an average sale price of $2,000,000.

Average Price: $2,000,000
View All Recent Sales divider

5. Rosewood Circle

Rosewood Circle is the 5th most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built from 2014 to 2020, ranging in price from $1,650,000 to $2,245,000. It is home to the Chaparral Pines subdivision.

Average Price: $1,947,500
View All Recent Sales divider

6. Genius Loci Street

Genius Loci Street is the 6th most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built in 2000, with an average sale price of $1,800,000.

Average Price: $1,800,000
View All Recent Sales divider

7. Roper Lane

Roper Lane is the 7th most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built in 2014, with an average sale price of $1,750,000.

Average Price: $1,750,000
View All Recent Sales divider

8. Redbud Circle

Redbud Circle is the 8th most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built from 2019 to 2020, ranging in price from $1,600,000 to $1,725,000. It is home to the Chaparral Pines subdivision.

Average Price: $1,662,500
View All Recent Sales divider

9. Senna Point

Senna Point is the 9th most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built in 2024, with an average sale price of $1,650,000. It is home to the Chaparral Pines subdivision.

Average Price: $1,650,000
View All Recent Sales divider

10. Pine Stream

Pine Stream is the 10th most expensive street in Payson. It has single-family homes built in 2015, with an average sale price of $1,650,000.

Average Price: $1,650,000
View All Recent Sales divider View All Homes for Sale in Payson
Sold Homes

We have helped over 8,000 families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.