St. James City, FL, Real Estate

St. James City, located at the southern tip of Pine Island in Lee County, Florida, is a charming, laid-back coastal community known for its serene waterfront views and small-town vibe. Nestled along the shores of Pine Island Sound, it offers a haven for boating, fishing, and nature enthusiasts, with easy access to the Gulf of Mexico and nearby islands like Sanibel and Captiva. The town’s history is rooted in fishing and agriculture, with a tight-knit community that values its tranquil lifestyle and natural beauty. Visitors and residents alike enjoy exploring local marinas, savoring fresh seafood at waterfront restaurants, and soaking in the unspoiled charm of this hidden gem, far from the hustle of larger Florida cities.

St. James City currently has 154 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $754,183.82, 9 condos for sale with an average list price of $320,500, and 142 lots for sale with an average list price of $210,762.89. The average annual property tax for St. James City is $4,207.49.

Current Homes for Sale

Schools

School District Level Grades
Pine Island Elementary School Lee School District Elementary PK, KG-5
Gulf Middle School Pasco School District Middle 6-8

Schools

View schools in St. James City

Browse St. James City

Absorption Report

Using the absorption rate, we can determine how long it's taking for homes to sell and which price points are selling the fastest in St. James City, i.e. what's hot and what's not.

See What's Hot & What's Not in St. James City

Recent Sales

View recent sales in St. James City

Subdivisions

Subdivisions Median Price
No Photos

Alden Acres Unrecorded Subdivision

Alden Acres Unrecorded Subdivision is a single-family home community in St. James City, Florida, built between 1984 and 2008. It currently has 2 lots for sale with an average list price of $38,875. The homes range in size from 1,280 ft2 to 2,134 ft2. The average annual property tax for Alden Acres Unrecorded Subdivision is $2,167.33. It is located in Lee County. ... Read more
No Photos

Bayview Acres

Bayview Acres is a single-family home community in St. James City, Florida, built between 1969 and 2018. It currently has 16 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $1,093,062.44. The homes range in size from 983 ft2 to 4,763 ft2. The average annual property tax for Bayview Acres is $6,868.25. It is located in Lee County. ... Read more
Median Price: $880,000
No Photos

Bayview Acres Replated

Bayview Acres Replated is a single-family home community in St. James City, Florida, built in 1970. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes have an average size of 2,409 ft2. The average annual property tax for Bayview Acres Replated is $6,991. It is located in Lee County. ... Read more
No Photos

Buccaneer Inn Condo

Buccaneer Inn Condo is a condo community in St. James City, Florida, built in 1974. It currently has 2 condos for sale with an average list price of $244,900. The homes range in size from 476 ft2 to 578 ft2. The HOA fees range from $347 to $347 per month. The average annual property tax for Buccaneer Inn Condo is $2,042.42. It is located in Lee County. ... Read more
No Photos

Buttonwood Key

Buttonwood Key is a single-family home community in St. James City, Florida, built between 1993 and 1999. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes range in size from 1,352 ft2 to 3,173 ft2. The HOA fees range from $17 to $33 per month. The average annual property tax for Buttonwood Key is $6,398.83. It is located in Lee County. ... Read more
Median Price: $581,500
Show all 47 Subdivisions

Subdivisions

View subdivisions in St. James City

Market Trends

View market trends in St. James City

Real Estate News

Homes Just Sold in St. James City: November 25th to December 1st

Homes Just Sold in St. James City: November 25th to December 1st - December 2, 2025

St. James City had 3 sales during the week of Tuesday, November 25 to Monday, December 1, including including 2 single family homes for sale with an average list price ... continue reading
New Homes with Gulf Access in St. James City: November 24th to November 30th

New Homes with Gulf Access in St. James City: November 24th to November 30th - December 1, 2025

St. James City had new homes for sale with gulf access during the month of Monday, November 24 to Sunday, November 30, including 3 single family homes for sale ... continue reading
New Homes with In-ground Swimming Pools in St. James City: November 23rd to November 29th

New Homes with In-ground Swimming Pools in St. James City: November 23rd to November 29th - November 30, 2025

St. James City had new homes for sale with an in-ground swimming pool during the month of Sunday, November 23 to Saturday, November 29, including 4 single family homes ... continue reading
New Homes For Sale This Week in St. James City: November 21st to November 27th

New Homes For Sale This Week in St. James City: November 21st to November 27th - November 28, 2025

St. James City had 6 new homes for sale during the week of Friday, November 21 to Thursday, November 27, including including 3 single family homes for sale with an ... continue reading
Homes Just Sold in St. James City: November 18th to November 24th

Homes Just Sold in St. James City: November 18th to November 24th - November 25, 2025

St. James City had 7 sales during the week of Tuesday, November 18 to Monday, November 24, including including 2 single family homes for sale with an average list price ... continue reading
View More St. James City News

Real Estate News

View More St. James City News

Sold Homes

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.