St. James City, FL Homes for Sale & Real Estate

St. James City, located at the southern tip of Pine Island in Lee County, Florida, is a charming, laid-back coastal community known for its serene waterfront views and small-town vibe. Nestled along the shores of Pine Island Sound, it offers a haven for boating, fishing, and nature enthusiasts, with easy access to the Gulf of Mexico and nearby islands like Sanibel and Captiva. The town’s history is rooted in fishing and agriculture, with a tight-knit community that values its tranquil lifestyle and natural beauty. Visitors and residents alike enjoy exploring local marinas, savoring fresh seafood at waterfront restaurants, and soaking in the unspoiled charm of this hidden gem, far from the hustle of larger Florida cities.

Location
County Lee County
State Florida
Averages
Taxes $3,672
House $804,030
Townhouse –
Condo $330,267

Homes for Sale

St. James City currently has 136 single family homes for sale, 6 condos for sale, 174 lots for sale, and 67 manufactured homes for sale. There is 1 foreclosure for sale, and 1 short sale. For anyone looking for a brand new home, there are 7 new construction homes for sale.

Want to know the moment a new home goes up for sale in St. James City?  Get Notified

Schools

St. James City, FL is served by Lee School District and Pasco School District. The area has 1 elementary school, 1 middle school.

Lee School District Elementary
Elementary Pine Island Elementary School Grades PK, KG-5
Pasco School District Middle
Middle Gulf Middle School Grades 6-8

Schools

View schools for St. James City

Marco Amidei
Marco Amidei
Real Estate Agent

Have questions? Looking to buy or sell? (888) 326-2726

Subdivisions in St. James City

St. James City has 44 subdivisions offering single family homes and condos. Prices range from $169,900 to $4,250,000. 7 subdivisions offer new construction homes. Cherry Estates currently has the most active listings with 50 homes for sale.

Browse All
44
Subdivisions in St. James City
View all Subdivisions
Hottest
50 active listings
Starter Homes
From $169,900
Luxury
Up to $4,250,000
Single Family
23
Subdivisions with houses for sale
Browse Subdivisions
Townhouses
0
Subdivisions with townhouses for sale
Browse Subdivisions
Condos
1
Subdivisions with condos for sale
Browse Subdivisions
New Construction
7
Subdivisions with new construction listings
Browse Subdivisions

Subdivisions

View subdivisions in St. James City

Market Trends

View market trends in St. James City

Real Estate News

View More St. James City News

Sold Homes

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.