Whitefish Bay, WI, Real Estate

Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, is a picturesque suburban village nestled along Lake Michigan’s shoreline, just north of Milwaukee, with a population of approximately 14,000. Known for its tree-lined streets, historic homes, and strong sense of community, it offers a blend of small-town charm and urban accessibility. The village features top-rated schools, vibrant local businesses along Silver Spring Drive, and scenic parks like Big Bay and Klode, perfect for lakeside strolls or family outings. With its rich architectural heritage, including stunning colonial and Tudor-style homes, and proximity to Milwaukee’s cultural attractions, Whitefish Bay is a sought-after destination for families and professionals seeking a high quality of life.

Whitefish Bay currently has 11 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $696,954.55 and 1 condo for sale with a list price of $186,900. The average annual property tax for Whitefish Bay is $8,528.69.

Current Homes for Sale

Schools

View schools in Whitefish Bay

Browse Whitefish Bay

Absorption Report

Using the absorption rate, we can determine how long it's taking for homes to sell and which price points are selling the fastest in Whitefish Bay, i.e. what's hot and what's not.

See What's Hot & What's Not in Whitefish Bay

Recent Sales

View recent sales in Whitefish Bay

Subdivisions/Buildings

Subdivisions/Buildings Median Price
No Photos

5600 Lake

5600 Lake is a condo building in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, built between 2005 and 2007. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes range in size from 1,305 ft2 to 3,107 ft2. The average annual property tax for 5600 Lake is $9,192.83. It is located in Milwaukee County. ... Read more
Median Price: $475,000
No Photos

Bay Shore Downs

Bay Shore Downs is a single-family home community in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, built in 1951. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes have an average size of 1,366 ft2. The average annual property tax for Bay Shore Downs is $4,147.29. It is located in Milwaukee County. Bay Shore Downs is located north of Silver Spring Drive and west of Santa Monica Blvd. ... Read more
No Photos

Clayton Terrace

Clayton Terrace is a condo community in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, built in 1975. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes range in size from 1,005 ft2 to 1,225 ft2. The average annual property tax for Clayton Terrace is $2,346.86. It is located in Milwaukee County. Clayton Terrace is located east of Santa Monica Blvd. and south of Henry Clay Street. ... Read more
Median Price: $175,000
No Photos

Claywood

Claywood is a condo community in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, built between 1967 and 1968. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes range in size from 1,135 ft2 to 1,240 ft2. The average annual property tax for Claywood is $2,318. It is located in Milwaukee County. Claywood is located on Henry Clay Street west of Marlborough Drive. ... Read more
Median Price: $209,000
No Photos

Country Day Park

Country Day Park is a subdivision in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin. It currently has no homes for sale. It is located in Milwaukee County. Country Day Park is located east of Port Washington Road and north of Devon Street. ... Read more
Show all 25 Subdivisions/Buildings

Subdivisions/Buildings

View subdivisions in Whitefish Bay

Market Trends

View market trends in Whitefish Bay

Real Estate News

New Homes For Sale This Week in Whitefish Bay: November 28th to December 4th

New Homes For Sale This Week in Whitefish Bay: November 28th to December 4th - December 5, 2025

Whitefish Bay had only 1 new home for sale during the week of Friday, November 28 to Thursday, December 4, including and it was a single family home for sale ... continue reading
Homes Just Sold in Whitefish Bay: November 25th to December 1st

Homes Just Sold in Whitefish Bay: November 25th to December 1st - December 2, 2025

Whitefish Bay had 3 sales during the week of Tuesday, November 25 to Monday, December 1, including including 3 single family homes for sale with an average list price of ... continue reading
New Homes For Sale This Week in Whitefish Bay: November 21st to November 27th

New Homes For Sale This Week in Whitefish Bay: November 21st to November 27th - November 28, 2025

Whitefish Bay had only 1 new home for sale during the week of Friday, November 21 to Thursday, November 27, including and it was a single family home for sale ... continue reading
Homes Just Sold in Whitefish Bay: November 18th to November 24th

Homes Just Sold in Whitefish Bay: November 18th to November 24th - November 25, 2025

Whitefish Bay had only 1 sale during the week of Tuesday, November 18 to Monday, November 24, including and it was a single family home for sale with a list ... continue reading
Homes Just Sold in Whitefish Bay: November 11th to November 17th

Homes Just Sold in Whitefish Bay: November 11th to November 17th - November 18, 2025

Whitefish Bay had 3 sales during the week of Tuesday, November 11 to Monday, November 17, including including 3 single family homes for sale with an average list price of ... continue reading
View More Whitefish Bay News

Real Estate News

View More Whitefish Bay News

Sold Homes

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.