Bay Colony, Cumming, GA, Real Estate

Get Notifications

Bay Colony is a single-family home community in Cumming, Georgia, built between 1982 and 2017. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes range in size from 1,296 ft2 to 4,383 ft2. The HOA fee is $77 per month. The average annual property tax for Bay Colony is $7,312.67. It is located in Forsyth County.

Bay Colony is located just west of Pilgrim Mill Road off Bay Circle. Situated on the picturesque shores of Lake Lanier, this subdivision of 41 homes offers residents a range of amenities, including a community dock, a fishing pond, two tennis courts, and a swimming pool. The neighborhood is served by the highly regarded Forsyth County School System, with schools like Forsyth Central High School earning accolades such as Georgia School of Excellence. Managed by the Bay Colony Homeowners Association, the community maintains standards to enhance property values and fosters a tight-knit environment, exemplified by its participation in the Nextdoor Pilgrim Mill network for neighborly communication and updates.

Boating Clubhouse Community Dock Dry Dock Fishing Gated Homeowners Assoc Lake Near Schools Near Shopping Near Trails/Greenway Park Playground Pool (Community) Powered Boats Allowed Sidewalks Street Lights Tennis Court(s) Waterfront

Location

City Cumming

County Forsyth

State Georgia

Averages

Taxes $7,313

House –

Townhouse –

Condo –

Homes for Sale

There are currently no homes for sale

Homes for Sale

View all homes for sale

Recent Sales

5130 Forest Hills Ct.

5130 Forest Hills Ct.

View All Recent Sales

Recent Sales

View recent sales in Bay Colony

Schools

Forsyth County School District Elementary, Middle, High School

Elementary Chattahoochee Elementary School Grades PK-5

Middle Little Mill Middle School Grades 6-8

High School East Forsyth High School Grades 9-12 Forsyth Central High School Grades 9-12

Schools

View schools for Bay Colony

Market Trends

Median Sale Price Sales Volume

Market Trends

View market trends for Bay Colony

Similar Subdivisions in Cumming

There are 188 other subdivisions in Cumming with a similar median price within 20% of $450,000.

Lanier Country Club Estates

Median: $450,000

Orchards of Habersham Grove

Orchards of Habersham Grove

Median: $450,000

Parnell Springs

Median: $450,000

Gatherings at Herrington

Gatherings at Herrington

Median: $450,000

Castleberry Place

Castleberry Place

Median: $448,000

Manchester Park

Median: $452,500

Median: $447,500

Walnut Grove

Median: $447,400

Summer Walk

Median: $452,950

Median: $453,750

Median: $446,250

Cottages at Greystone

Cottages at Greystone

Median: $454,500

Shiloh Woods

Median: $455,000

Median: $455,000

Bethwicke

Median: $445,000

Muirfield at Windermere

Muirfield at Windermere

Median: $455,000

Median: $457,450

Southlake Estates

Median: $442,500

Median: $442,000

Median: $441,250

Median: $459,800

Median: $459,900

Timberline at Lake Lanier

Timberline at Lake Lanier

Median: $440,000

Median: $460,000

Millstone

Median: $460,000

Sidney Mill

Median: $440,000

Parkside at Pilgrim Mill

Parkside at Pilgrim Mill

Median: $460,000

Median: $440,000

Hemingway Townhomes

Median: $439,990

Median: $461,332.50

Little Mill Landing

Little Mill Landing

Median: $461,500

Median: $437,500

Pilgrim Landing

Median: $462,500

Berryhill

Median: $437,500

Hendrix Place

Median: $462,750

Paddocks Mill

Median: $437,000

Median: $435,500

Settendown Reserve

Settendown Reserve

Median: $435,000

Median: $465,000

Median: $434,000

Greystone Forest

Median: $466,500

Median: $432,000

Piedmont Corners

Piedmont Corners

Median: $469,450

Median: $430,000

Canterbury Farms

Canterbury Farms

Median: $470,000

Manchester Court

Median: $430,000

Harris Creek

Median: $470,000

Median: $470,000

Phoenix Heights

Median: $430,000

High Pointe View

Median: $470,000

Starr Creek Forest

Median: $429,000

Median: $471,000

Whispering Brook

Median: $428,000

Median: $427,500

The Court at Bethelview

Median: $474,000

The Springs at Burnt Bridge

Median: $475,000

Median: $425,000

Median: $425,000

Median: $425,000

Villas at Castleberry Township

Villas at Castleberry Township

Median: $475,000

Median: $475,000

Pilgrim Mill Station

Median: $425,000

Market Square at Sawnee Village

Median: $424,900

Stonehaven Pointe

Median: $475,125

Median: $477,000

Median: $477,500

Median: $422,500

Ansley at Pilgrim Mill

Ansley at Pilgrim Mill

Median: $422,000

Bridgetowne

Median: $420,000

Pinnacle Glen

Median: $420,000

Median: $480,000

Median: $420,000

Fieldstone Court

Fieldstone Court

Median: $480,000

Median: $480,000

Median: $420,000

Median: $481,250

Mountain View Estates

Median: $418,500

Crescent Landing

Median: $482,000

Median: $482,500

Bridgeport at Young Deer

Median: $483,000

Median: $483,100

Stablegate at Mountain Crest

Stablegate at Mountain Crest

Median: $483,500

Montclair

Median: $485,000

Median: $415,000

Madison Springs

Median: $486,200

Median: $413,500

Parkside Village

Median: $487,500

Chadwick Crossing

Chadwick Crossing

Median: $412,500

Median: $412,500

Jefferson Place

Median: $489,000

Andover Glen

Median: $489,950

Country Estates

Median: $410,000

Churchill Downs

Churchill Downs

Median: $490,000

Wade Valley Overlook

Median: $410,000

Overlook at Carriage Walk

Median: $410,000

Median: $408,750

Cambridge Hills

Cambridge Hills

Median: $492,450

The Villages at Castleberry

Median: $407,500

Median: $407,500

Median: $407,450

Newbury

Median: $406,000

Median: $406,000

Greystone Trace

Median: $495,000

Woodcreek

Median: $405,000

Highland Ridge

Median: $405,000

Valley Stream

Median: $495,000

Hurt Bridge Park

Median: $403,000

Villages at Settingdown Creek

Villages at Settingdown Creek

Median: $497,500

Median: $497,500

Big Creek Township

Median: $497,999

Adair Park

Median: $498,500

Median: $401,500

Median: $499,000

Median: $400,250

Median: $499,990

Fieldstone Park

Fieldstone Park

Median: $500,000

Stonebrooke Commons

Median: $400,000

Carriage Walk

Median: $400,000

Blackburn Ridge

Blackburn Ridge

Median: $500,000

Median: $400,000

Median: $500,000

Orchards of Central Park

Median: $500,000

Median: $399,000

Rose Hill

Median: $399,000

Westwind

Median: $501,250

Median: $398,000

Brookhaven at Lanier Ridge

Brookhaven at Lanier Ridge

Median: $502,500

The Haven at Bethelview

Median: $502,500

Emerald Springs

Median: $397,450

Bentley Farms

Median: $503,600

Median: $505,000

Median: $505,000

Chamblee Estates

Median: $505,750

Median: $394,000

Habersham on Lanier

Habersham on Lanier

Median: $507,500

Midway Village

Median: $508,000

Townhouses at Lanier

Townhouses at Lanier

Median: $508,500

Old Towne Bethelview

Old Towne Bethelview

Median: $509,000

Marketplace Commons

Median: $510,000

The Estates At Starr Creek

Median: $510,000

Median: $512,500

Autumn Walk

Median: $512,500

Burnt Bridge at Settendown

Median: $512,500

Greenwood Acres

Median: $514,000

Median: $385,000

Median: $385,000

Moores Crossing

Median: $385,000

Orchards of Brannon Oak Farm

Orchards of Brannon Oak Farm

Median: $515,000

Median: $385,000

Median: $384,000

Median: $516,750

Median: $517,450

Wynfield

Median: $517,500

Hutchinson Trace

Median: $380,500

Orchard Lake

Median: $520,000

Median: $520,000

Cannongate on Lanier

Median: $523,000

Stonehaven Terrace

Median: $376,000

Whispering Lake

Median: $525,000

Longview

Median: $375,000

Median: $525,000

Median: $375,000

Delamar

Median: $525,000

Bald Ridge Shores

Median: $525,000

Median: $374,000

Habersham Pointe

Habersham Pointe

Median: $527,000

Median: $373,000

Sherwood Forest

Median: $527,450

Timberland Heights

Timberland Heights

Median: $527,500

Eagle Creek Shores

Median: $372,000

Geneva Woods

Median: $528,500

Median: $528,870

Forsyth Estates

Median: $530,000

Kingswood at Castleberry

Median: $531,500

Shiloh Creek

Median: $531,500

Median: $367,500

Sweetbriar

Median: $532,500

Bridlewood

Median: $533,000

Median: $533,500

Median: $366,266.50

Deep Cove

Median: $366,000

Median: $535,000

Bramblett Grove

Bramblett Grove

Median: $537,500

Concord Farms

Median: $540,000

Median: $540,000

Median: $540,000

Median: $540,000

Median: $360,000

Show All 188 Subdivisions

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.

Karen & Ali Stafford-Shah

Preston & Nancy Reed

David & Tiffany Noel

Leo & Scott Spande

Trinity Truong & Andy Vo

Keith & Kris Konieczny

Harrison Murphy

Quang Kim Truong & Thuy Thu Dang

Other Cities/States

Listings identified with the FMLS IDX logo come from FMLS, are held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website and the listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. If you believe any FMLS listing contains material that infringes your copyrighted work please contact us to learn how to submit a takedown request. Copyright © 2026 First Multiple Listing Service, Inc.

Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage, 6290 Abbotts Bridge Road, Johns Creek, GA, 30097

Powered by HomesByMarco