Butler Bay, Windermere, FL, Real Estate

About Butler Bay

Butler Bay is a single-family home community in Windermere, Florida, built between 1983 and 2008. It currently has 3 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $2,261,333.33. The homes range in size from 2,649 ft2 to 6,819 ft2. The HOA fees range from $108 to $392 per month. The average annual property tax for Butler Bay is $11,901.21. It is located in Orange County.

Butler Bay is a desirable residential neighborhood, renowned for its serene lakeside setting and relaxed upscale living. Nestled near the Butler Chain of Lakes, including scenic spots like Lake Crescent and Lake Roberts, the area features expansive single-family homes—many waterfront or lake-view—with spacious lots shaded by mature trees.

Developed primarily since the 1980s, Butler Bay includes established subdivisions such as the Manors at Butler Bay and parts associated with the Windermere Club, offering a mix of luxury properties ranging from mid-six figures to well over a million dollars. Residents enjoy a peaceful, family-friendly atmosphere with strong community ties, proximity to downtown Windermere's quaint shops and dining, and convenient access to Orlando attractions, making it an idyllic escape that balances tranquility with Central Florida's vibrant lifestyle.

Boat Facilities   Cats Allowed   Dock   Dogs Allowed   Fishing   Gated   Golf   Golf Carts OK   Lake   Maintenance Grounds   Park   Playground   Pool (Community)   Recreation Area   Security   Sidewalks   Street Lights   Tennis Court(s)   Water Access   Waterfront