Pilgrim Bay, Cumming, GA, Real Estate

Get Notifications

Pilgrim Bay is a single-family home community in Cumming, Georgia, built between 1973 and 1997. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes range in size from 1,392 ft2 to 3,013 ft2. The HOA fee is $17 per month. The average annual property tax for Pilgrim Bay is $5,972. It is located in Forsyth County.

Pilgrim Bay is located off of Pilgrim Point Road south of Mercedes Drive, near the scenic shores of Lake Lanier. . The community offers exclusive amenities like a community dock and nature trail within walking distance, making it ideal for swimming, kayaking, and boating enthusiasts. Its prime location provides easy access to schools, shopping, and Lake Lanier boat ramps, blending suburban tranquility with recreational convenience.

Boating Community Dock Fishing Homeowners Assoc Lake Marina Near Schools Near Shopping Park Powered Boats Allowed Restaurant Street Lights Waterfront

Location

City Cumming

County Forsyth

State Georgia

Averages

Taxes $5,972

House –

Townhouse –

Condo –

Homes for Sale

There are currently no homes for sale

Homes for Sale

View all homes for sale

Recent Sales

5560 Pilgrim Point Extension

5470 Linger Longer Rd.

5470 Linger Longer Rd.

5410 Pilgrim Point Rd.

View All Recent Sales

Recent Sales

View recent sales in Pilgrim Bay

Schools

Forsyth County School District Elementary, Middle, High School

Elementary Chattahoochee Elementary School Grades PK-5

Middle Little Mill Middle School Grades 6-8

High School East Forsyth High School Grades 9-12

Schools

View schools for Pilgrim Bay

Market Trends

Median Sale Price Sales Volume

Market Trends

View market trends for Pilgrim Bay

Similar Subdivisions in Cumming

There are 268 other subdivisions in Cumming with a similar median price within 20% of $587,500.

Evans Farms

Median: $587,500

The Village at Herrington

Median: $587,404

Median: $585,000

Barrett Downs

Median: $590,000

Whitfield

Median: $590,000

The Preserve at Brookwood

The Preserve at Brookwood

Median: $590,250

Settlers Lake

Median: $594,000

Dressage

Median: $594,500

Chestnut Springs

Chestnut Springs

Median: $594,900

Saddlebrook

Median: $580,000

Wallace Run

Median: $595,000

Villas at Bethelview

Villas at Bethelview

Median: $595,000

Belmont Downs

Median: $580,000

Pilgrim Mill Landing

Median: $595,000

Westhaven

Median: $597,000

Bridlewood at Mountain Crest

Median: $597,500

The Manor at Kingswood

Median: $576,200

Charleston Bay

Median: $599,000

Highland Pointe

Highland Pointe

Median: $599,000

Saddlebrook Glen

Saddlebrook Glen

Median: $599,500

Hunters Walk

Median: $600,000

Fieldstone Glen

Median: $575,000

The Summit at Brookwood

The Summit at Brookwood

Median: $575,000

Hickory Ridge

Median: $600,000

Canongate on Lanier

Canongate on Lanier

Median: $575,000

Gates at Castleberry

Median: $575,000

Smithdale Acres

Median: $600,000

Median: $600,000

Ansley Park

Median: $574,000

East Ridge at Stoney Point

East Ridge at Stoney Point

Median: $602,500

Median: $572,500

Saddle Ridge

Median: $602,500

Median: $602,595

Orchards of South Forsyth

Median: $572,045

Thorngate

Median: $570,000

Carruth Lake Estates

Median: $605,000

The Lakes at Franklin Goldmine

The Lakes at Franklin Goldmine

Median: $570,000

The Enclave

Median: $605,000

Median: $569,592

South Shore Woods on Lanier

Median: $606,000

Vickery Downs

Median: $568,900

Union Station

Median: $568,500

Median: $606,500

Tiberon on the Etowah

Median: $566,500

Median: $566,281.50

Ellington

Median: $565,250

Parkstone

Median: $610,000

Post Oak Glen

Median: $565,000

Median: $565,000

Majors Mill Crossing

Majors Mill Crossing

Median: $610,200

Abbey Glen

Median: $564,500

Fieldstone Enclave

Fieldstone Enclave

Median: $612,450

Median: $562,000

Hampton Golf Village

Median: $614,900

Median: $615,000

Bentley Ridge

Median: $560,000

The Villas at Habersham

The Villas at Habersham

Median: $558,500

North Cove

Median: $618,290

Bethany Springs

Bethany Springs

Median: $619,500

Fox Creek

Median: $620,000

Shiloh Pointe

Median: $620,000

Villages at Concord Farms

Villages at Concord Farms

Median: $555,000

Heatherstone

Median: $555,000

Median: $555,000

The Reserve at The Villages at Castleberry

Median: $621,000

Brookside

Median: $621,500

Danbury Farms

Median: $622,500

Median: $622,500

The Highlands at Sawnee Mountain

The Highlands at Sawnee Mountain

Median: $625,000

Median: $550,000

Ivey Manor

Median: $625,000

Orchards of Stoney Point

Orchards of Stoney Point

Median: $550,000

Avalon

Median: $625,000

Ivey Falls

Median: $625,000

River Manor

Median: $625,000

The Park at Kelly Mill

The Park at Kelly Mill

Median: $625,000

Median: $625,000

The Towns at Westshore

Median: $550,000

Shiloh Preserve

Median: $550,000

The Farms at Mountain Ridge

Median: $625,403

Median: $549,593

Maristone

Median: $627,000

Season's Preserve at Hyde Park

Season's Preserve at Hyde Park

Median: $547,900

Median: $627,500

Wills Orchard

Median: $627,700

Peachtree Court

Peachtree Court

Median: $547,000

Brighton View

Median: $628,750

Sawnee View Farms

Sawnee View Farms

Median: $546,240

Median: $545,000

Median: $630,000

Cobblestone

Median: $545,000

The Enclave at Waterford

The Enclave at Waterford

Median: $630,000

The Reserve at Settlers Lake

The Reserve at Settlers Lake

Median: $630,000

Carriage Park

Median: $631,000

Glenmoor

Median: $542,500

High Meadows at Mountain Crest

Median: $634,375

Concord Farms

Median: $540,000

Median: $540,000

Median: $540,000

Coopers Ridge

Median: $635,000

Hampton Forest

Median: $635,000

Median: $540,000

Overlook at Habersham Pointe

Overlook at Habersham Pointe

Median: $635,000

Bramblett Grove

Bramblett Grove

Median: $537,500

Cobblestone Farms

Median: $637,500

Median: $637,500

Old Atlanta Commons

Old Atlanta Commons

Median: $637,500

Palisades at Sawnee Village

Median: $639,000

The Manor at Harmon Lake

The Manor at Harmon Lake

Median: $639,900

Springmonte

Median: $640,000

Median: $535,000

Median: $533,500

Bridlewood

Median: $533,000

Sweetbriar

Median: $532,500

Carriage Cove at Mountain Crest

Median: $642,500

Median: $643,000

Kingswood at Castleberry

Median: $531,500

Shiloh Creek

Median: $531,500

Plantation at Brookwood

Plantation at Brookwood

Median: $645,000

Median: $645,000

Median: $645,000

Forsyth Estates

Median: $530,000

Median: $645,000

Median: $645,824

Median: $528,870

Geneva Woods

Median: $528,500

Timberland Heights

Timberland Heights

Median: $527,500

Sherwood Forest

Median: $527,450

Habersham Pointe

Habersham Pointe

Median: $527,000

Bald Ridge on Lanier

Median: $649,000

Median: $649,447.50

Sentinel Grove

Median: $649,900

Whispering Lake

Median: $525,000

Avington

Median: $650,000

Median: $650,000

Median: $525,000

Estates at Big Creek

Estates at Big Creek

Median: $650,000

Majors Ridge

Median: $650,000

Delamar

Median: $525,000

Westfield

Median: $650,000

The Vineyards

Median: $650,000

Bald Ridge Shores

Median: $525,000

Whisper Woods at Majors

Median: $650,000

Glenhaven at Hampton

Median: $651,000

Cannongate on Lanier

Median: $523,000

Orchard Lake

Median: $520,000

Montvale

Median: $655,000

Vickery Lake

Median: $655,000

Median: $520,000

Fairway Estates

Fairway Estates

Median: $655,000

Wynfield

Median: $517,500

Median: $517,450

Median: $516,750

Orchards of Brannon Oak Farm

Orchards of Brannon Oak Farm

Median: $515,000

Greenwood Acres

Median: $514,000

Park Shore

Median: $662,500

Median: $512,500

Autumn Walk

Median: $512,500

Burnt Bridge at Settendown

Median: $512,500

Median: $663,000

Saddlewood at Mountain Crest

Median: $664,500

Median: $665,000

Median: $665,000

Marketplace Commons

Median: $510,000

Stone View

Median: $665,000

The Estates At Starr Creek

Median: $510,000

Old Towne Bethelview

Old Towne Bethelview

Median: $509,000

Median: $666,069

Townhouses at Lanier

Townhouses at Lanier

Median: $508,500

Midway Village

Median: $508,000

Habersham on Lanier

Habersham on Lanier

Median: $507,500

The Ridge at Stoney Point

The Ridge at Stoney Point

Median: $668,500

Courtyards at Traditions

Median: $668,500

Chamblee Estates

Median: $505,750

Post Preserve

Median: $669,910.50

Liberty

Median: $670,000

Pleasant Manor Estates

Median: $670,000

Median: $505,000

Heard Forest at Lanier

Median: $670,000

Median: $505,000

Bentley Farms

Median: $503,600

Princeton Square

Princeton Square

Median: $672,500

Brookhaven at Lanier Ridge

Brookhaven at Lanier Ridge

Median: $502,500

The Haven at Bethelview

Median: $502,500

Westwind

Median: $501,250

Blackstock Mill

Median: $675,000

Fieldstone Park

Fieldstone Park

Median: $500,000

Blackburn Ridge

Blackburn Ridge

Median: $500,000

Median: $500,000

Median: $675,000

Orchards of Central Park

Median: $500,000

Fairview

Median: $675,000

Arden Greens at Windermere

Median: $675,000

Median: $499,990

Woodruff on The Creek

Woodruff on The Creek

Median: $675,950

Median: $499,000

Adair Park

Median: $498,500

Hamby Farms

Median: $676,500

Big Creek Township

Median: $497,999

Villages at Settingdown Creek

Villages at Settingdown Creek

Median: $497,500

Median: $497,500

Median: $678,408

Median: $679,711

Silver Leaf

Median: $680,000

Greystone Trace

Median: $495,000

Parkside on Post

Parkside on Post

Median: $680,000

Median: $680,000

Valley Stream

Median: $495,000

Thalley Creek Estates

Median: $680,000

Cambridge Hills

Cambridge Hills

Median: $492,450

Median: $684,000

Median: $685,000

Churchill Downs

Churchill Downs

Median: $490,000

Andover Glen

Median: $489,950

Grandview Manor

Median: $685,457.50

Jefferson Place

Median: $489,000

Fox Chase

Median: $687,000

Parkside Village

Median: $487,500

Median: $688,500

Coventry

Median: $688,750

Madison Springs

Median: $486,200

Montclair

Median: $485,000

Sharon Walk

Median: $690,000

Margate

Median: $690,000

Carriage Post

Median: $690,000

Promenade at Sawnee Village

Median: $690,907.50

Traditions at Herrington

Median: $691,000

Stablegate at Mountain Crest

Stablegate at Mountain Crest

Median: $483,500

Settingdown Farms

Median: $691,745

Median: $483,100

Bridgeport at Young Deer

Median: $483,000

Median: $482,500

The Commons at Longlake

Median: $692,500

Crescent Landing

Median: $482,000

Median: $481,250

Ryans Bluff

Median: $694,000

Hopewell Reserve

Median: $694,209

Newgate at Windermere

Newgate at Windermere

Median: $694,950

Median: $480,000

Fieldstone Court

Fieldstone Court

Median: $480,000

Median: $480,000

Median: $697,000

Median: $477,500

Median: $697,500

West Oaks

Median: $698,000

Median: $477,000

Median: $698,329

Bellehurst

Median: $698,500

Northern Oaks

Median: $699,000

Westerleigh Commons

Westerleigh Commons

Median: $699,500

Stonehaven Pointe

Median: $475,125

Median: $699,900

Daves Creek Reserve

Daves Creek Reserve

Median: $700,000

Telfair

Median: $700,000

The Springs at Burnt Bridge

Median: $475,000

Villas at Castleberry Township

Villas at Castleberry Township

Median: $475,000

Median: $475,000

Median: $701,000

The Court at Bethelview

Median: $474,000

Median: $471,000

The Park at Bethelview

Median: $704,484

Woodbury Preserve

Woodbury Preserve

Median: $704,900

Canterbury Farms

Canterbury Farms

Median: $470,000

Twelve Oaks Place

Median: $705,000

Haw Creek

Median: $705,000

Harris Creek

Median: $470,000

Median: $470,000

High Pointe View

Median: $470,000

Show All 268 Subdivisions

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.

Hai Le & Sanhan Nguyen

Ronald & Lanelle Shuffler

Joe & Jan Labriola

Stephen & Cammie Koo

Patrick & Melissa Ragan

Robert & Benita Petty

Lal Thang & Thanda Mawia

Gail Ingle

Other Cities/States

Listings identified with the FMLS IDX logo come from FMLS, are held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website and the listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. If you believe any FMLS listing contains material that infringes your copyrighted work please contact us to learn how to submit a takedown request. Copyright © 2026 First Multiple Listing Service, Inc.

Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage, 6290 Abbotts Bridge Road, Johns Creek, GA, 30097

Powered by HomesByMarco