Sapphire Shores, Indian Beach Sapphire Shores, Sarasota, FL, Real Estate

Get Notifications

Sapphire Shores is a single-family home and land community in the Indian Beach Sapphire Shores neighborhood of Sarasota, Florida. It currently has 7 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $4,099,985.71 and 6 lots for sale with an average list price of $3,044,166.67. For anyone looking for a brand new home, there are 3 new construction homes for sale. The HOA fees range from $2 to $125 per month. The average annual property tax for Sapphire Shores is $18,550.25. It is located in Sarasota County.

Sapphire Shores is a charming and highly desirable bayfront community that blends historic Old Florida character with modern luxury. Tucked between U.S. 41 and Sarasota Bay just south of the John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art, this eclectic area features a mix of beautifully preserved historic homes, waterfront properties, and newer residences shaded by mature oaks, banyans, and palms.

Residents enjoy exceptional access to Sarasota Bay through parks like Indian Beach Park (popular for kayaking, canoeing, and sunset viewing), as well as sidewalks that make the neighborhood walkable and inviting. With convenient proximity to downtown Sarasota, the airport, and University Parkway, yet a peaceful, vibrant atmosphere, Indian Beach-Sapphire Shores stands out as one of Sarasota’s hidden waterfront gems—offering a rich lifestyle where cultural amenities, natural beauty, and community spirit come together seamlessly.

Airport/Runway Boat Facilities Boat Ramp Cats Allowed Dock Dogs Allowed Fishing Golf Carts OK Gulf Access Marina Park Playground Sidewalks Street Lights Water Access Waterfront

Location

Neighborhood Indian Beach Sapphire Shores

City Sarasota

County Sarasota

State Florida

Averages

Taxes $18,550

House $4,099,986

Townhouse –

Condo –

Homes for Sale

4946 Brywill Cir.

387 S Shore Dr.

337 N Shore Dr.

View All Homes For Sale

Homes for Sale

View all homes for sale

Recent Sales

4875 Brywill Cir.

418 Sapphire Dr.

428 Sapphire Dr.

5035 Bay Shore Rd.

View All Recent Sales

Recent Sales

View recent sales in Sapphire Shores

Schools

Sarasota County School District Elementary, Middle, High School

Elementary Bay Haven School Of Basics Plus Grades K-5 Emma E. Booker Elementary School Grades PK, KG-5 Phillippi Shores Elementary School Grades PK, KG-5

Middle Booker Middle School Grades 6-8 Brookside Middle School Grades 6-8

High School Booker High School Grades 9-12 Sarasota High School Grades 9-12

Schools

View schools for Sapphire Shores

Market Trends

Median Sale Price Sales Volume

Market Trends

View market trends for Sapphire Shores

Similar Subdivisions in Sarasota

There are 85 other subdivisions in Sarasota with a similar median price within 20% of $1,225,000.

Mooring at Bay Pointe

Median: $1,225,000

Sarasota Surf and Racquet Club

Median: $1,225,000

Johnson Estates South

Median: $1,230,000

Median: $1,235,000

Monterey at Lakewood Ranch

Median: $1,237,500

Median: $1,212,500

Median: $1,240,000

Shoreland Woods

Median: $1,242,500

Bel Air Estates

Median: $1,200,000

Siestas Bayside Waterside East

Median: $1,200,000

Median: $1,200,000

Terrace Gardens

Median: $1,200,000

Median: $1,200,000

Median: $1,250,000

Median: $1,262,500

Median: $1,187,250

Shellstone at Waterside

Median: $1,179,416

Key Towers South

Median: $1,275,000

Rollins Pond Estates

Median: $1,175,000

Median: $1,170,000

Condo on the Bay

Median: $1,170,000

Median: $1,280,000

The Alcove at Waterside

Median: $1,293,656

Lakehouse Cove at Waterside

Median: $1,150,000

Valencia Rosemary Place

Median: $1,300,000

Median: $1,150,000

Median: $1,150,000

Median: $1,150,000

Siestas Bayside First Bayside Club

Median: $1,300,000

Median: $1,150,000

Sarasota Heights

Median: $1,300,000

Median: $1,147,500

Median: $1,312,500

Median: $1,125,000

Premier on Main

Median: $1,124,000

Shoreview at Waterside

Median: $1,327,500

The Ranches at Bern Creek

Median: $1,332,500

Median: $1,112,500

Median: $1,337,500

Median: $1,342,000

Lawrence Pointe

Median: $1,107,900

Median: $1,350,000

Median: $1,100,000

Laurel Oak Estates

Median: $1,350,000

Median: $1,100,000

Median: $1,100,000

The Mark Sarasota

Median: $1,350,000

Median: $1,100,000

Median: $1,095,000

Palm Avenue Villas

Median: $1,095,000

Gulf and Bay Club

Median: $1,094,550

Siesta Breakers

Median: $1,087,000

Median: $1,085,000

Median: $1,078,750

Wood Ridge at the Meadows

Median: $1,375,000

Median: $1,075,000

Median: $1,075,000

Median: $1,388,500

Artistry Sarasota

Median: $1,058,112.50

Median: $1,055,000

Siesta Sands Beach Resort

Median: $1,398,000

Median: $1,400,000

Median: $1,050,000

Median: $1,050,000

Median: $1,050,000

Sanderling Club

Median: $1,400,000

St Armand Towers

Median: $1,050,000

Median: $1,050,000

Median: $1,047,500

Median: $1,045,000

Jamaica Royale Tower

Median: $1,036,500

Median: $1,035,000

Phillippi Pines

Median: $1,032,500

Median: $1,012,500

Hudson Landings

Median: $1,007,250

High Point Circle

Median: $1,000,000

Westwood by Myakka Valley

Median: $1,000,000

Median: $999,000

Median: $1,451,000

Point of Rocks Terrace

Median: $1,452,500

Median: $1,455,000

Siesta Bayside South

Median: $1,462,500

Myakka Valley Ranches

Median: $987,500

Sarasota Plantations

Median: $985,000

Median: $980,000

Show All 85 Subdivisions

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.