St Michaels Bay, Cumming, GA, Real Estate

Get Notifications

St Michaels Bay in Cumming

St Michaels Bay is a single-family home community in Cumming, Georgia, built between 1984 and 2022. It currently has 2 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $986,700. The homes range in size from 2,853 ft2 to 6,684 ft2. The HOA fees range from $88 to $342 per month. The average annual property tax for St Michaels Bay is $7,121.67. It is located in Forsyth County.

St Michaels Bay is located south of Parks Road and west of Little Mill Road. St Michaels Bay is north of Lake Lanier and includes amenities such as a pool, tennis courts, clubhouse, fitness room, playground and walking trails.

Boating Clubhouse Community Dock Fishing Fitness Center Gated Homeowners Assoc Lake Marina Near Schools Near Shopping Near Trails/Greenway Park Pickleball Playground Pool (Community) Powered Boats Allowed Sidewalks Street Lights Tennis Court(s) Waterfront

Location

City Cumming

County Forsyth

State Georgia

Averages

Taxes $7,122

House $986,700

Townhouse –

Condo –

Homes for Sale

6230 Leeward Tide Ct.

6040 Windjammer Point

View All Homes For Sale

Homes for Sale

View all homes for sale

Recent Sales

6010 Anchorage Quay

5855 Windjammer Point

5780 Windjammer Point

6345 Sterling Shores Dr.

View All Recent Sales

Recent Sales

View recent sales in St Michaels Bay

Schools

Forsyth County School District Elementary, Middle, High School

Elementary Chattahoochee Elementary School Grades PK-5

Middle Little Mill Middle School Grades 6-8

High School East Forsyth High School Grades 9-12

Schools

View schools for St Michaels Bay

Market Trends

Median Sale Price Sales Volume

Market Trends

View market trends for St Michaels Bay

Similar Subdivisions in Cumming

There are 120 other subdivisions in Cumming with a similar median price within 20% of $957,500.

Median: $957,063.50

Median: $958,440

Herrington Glen

Median: $955,000

Median: $953,365

Median: $962,815

Churchill Crossing

Churchill Crossing

Median: $965,000

Rosewood Lake

Median: $949,750

East Village at Windermere

Median: $966,250

Hadley Estates

Median: $948,000

Lakeside Farms

Median: $967,500

Median: $967,500

High Branch

Median: $945,000

Vickery Village

Vickery Village

Median: $942,500

The Gables at Stoney Point

The Gables at Stoney Point

Median: $975,000

Lochmar

Median: $975,000

Arden on Lanier

Median: $977,304

Provence

Median: $937,500

Median: $979,121

Driskell Shores

Median: $979,625

Westbrook

Median: $980,000

Davis Farms

Median: $980,000

Holbrook Estates

Median: $980,000

Median: $933,500

Cascading Creek Estates

Cascading Creek Estates

Median: $930,000

Cool Springs

Median: $987,500

Deer Creek Shores

Median: $927,500

Seneca

Median: $990,000

Median: $990,000

Bentley Commons

Median: $925,000

Median: $920,745

Marseille

Median: $920,000

The Cottages at Creekstone

The Cottages at Creekstone

Median: $995,000

Aaronmoor

Median: $920,000

Benson Oaks

Median: $995,550

Woodland Park

Median: $917,500

Median: $999,183.50

Fieldstone Preserve

Fieldstone Preserve

Median: $1,000,000

Reserve at Lakeview

Reserve at Lakeview

Median: $915,000

Young Deer Harbour

Median: $915,000

Bald Ridge Acres

Median: $915,000

Chattahoochee Reserve

Median: $908,945

Copper Creek

Median: $907,450

Tullamore

Median: $1,012,500

Calamar

Median: $1,015,000

Ridge Mill Acres

Median: $900,000

Median: $900,000

The Crossing at Coal Mountain

Median: $900,000

Lake Astoria

Median: $897,500

Southgate Village at Windermere

Median: $897,500

Polo Golf and Country Club

Polo Golf and Country Club

Median: $891,000

Fairfield Farms

Fairfield Farms

Median: $1,025,000

Chatsworth Manor

Chatsworth Manor

Median: $1,027,000

Cheswyck

Median: $1,029,000

Bethelwood Lakes

Median: $885,000

Median: $885,000

Traditions

Median: $880,000

Balmoral

Median: $1,037,500

Lake Forest

Median: $875,000

Creekstone Point

Creekstone Point

Median: $1,040,000

Median: $1,040,000

The Legends of Settendown Creek

The Legends of Settendown Creek

Median: $1,041,000

Forest Brooke

Median: $872,979.50

Meadow Creek Farm

Median: $872,500

Edgebrook at James Creek

Edgebrook at James Creek

Median: $870,000

Breeze Bay on Lanier

Median: $869,000

The Cottages at Daves Creek

The Cottages at Daves Creek

Median: $1,050,000

Wolf Creek Park

Median: $862,500

Castleton at Windermere

Median: $860,000

Median: $1,060,000

Shiloh Manor

Median: $854,000

Median: $1,065,000

Three Chimneys Farm

Three Chimneys Farm

Median: $850,000

Median: $850,000

Madison

Median: $850,000

Sierra Lake

Median: $850,000

The Estates at Old Atlanta

The Estates at Old Atlanta

Median: $850,000

Martingale at Mountain Crest

Median: $850,000

Woodland Reserve

Woodland Reserve

Median: $848,650

Brandon Hall

Median: $845,000

Median: $845,000

Chatsworth

Median: $1,075,000

Brentwood Estates

Brentwood Estates

Median: $840,000

Meadowbrook Farms

Median: $837,279

Median: $830,000

Median: $1,090,000

Median: $824,950

Chattahoochee River Club

Chattahoochee River Club

Median: $824,500

Trammel Estates

Median: $820,000

Median: $820,000

Trammel Ridge

Median: $817,500

Stonecrest at Johns Creek

Stonecrest at Johns Creek

Median: $815,000

Median: $1,100,000

Caney Creek

Median: $810,500

Somerdale

Median: $810,000

Heritage Manor

Median: $810,000

Median: $809,150

Estates at Majors

Median: $805,000

Median: $803,172.50

The Grove at Spring Valley

The Grove at Spring Valley

Median: $802,000

Sentinel Chase

Median: $801,000

Vistas at Castleberry

Vistas at Castleberry

Median: $800,000

Notting Hill

Median: $800,000

Ashebrooke

Median: $799,500

Fields Bridge

Median: $799,500

Median: $799,000

Parc at Creekstone

Parc at Creekstone

Median: $795,000

Stonegate

Median: $793,500

Arbor Chase

Median: $792,775

Wildbrooke

Median: $790,000

Estates at Creekside

Median: $790,000

Kelly Mill Reserve

Median: $790,000

Kensington at Windermere

Median: $785,000

Median: $1,135,000

Montebello

Median: $778,000

Median: $774,900

Bentley Hills

Median: $774,000

Farrington at Windermere

Median: $1,142,500

Sheffield

Median: $771,500

Median: $771,100

The Cottages at Westshore

Median: $770,000

Show All 120 Subdivisions

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.

Matt Warman

Hai Le & Sanhan Nguyen

Garry Blackwelder & Tammy Campbell-Rastello

Mirka Nawara

Earl & Teri Duffey

Jeff Mekolites & Johanna Wise

Sylvester Spencer & Jeanette Coxton

Edilia Rojas

Other Cities/States

Listings identified with the FMLS IDX logo come from FMLS, are held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website and the listing brokerage is identified in any listing details. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. If you believe any FMLS listing contains material that infringes your copyrighted work please contact us to learn how to submit a takedown request. Copyright © 2026 First Multiple Listing Service, Inc.

Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage, 6290 Abbotts Bridge Road, Johns Creek, GA, 30097

Powered by HomesByMarco