Bay Island, Sarasota, FL, Real Estate

Bay Island is a waterfront neighborhood located in Sarasota, Florida. It is situated on a small peninsula surrounded by Sarasota Bay and is known for its beautiful views, tranquil atmosphere, and upscale homes.

The neighborhood is located just south of the Ringling Causeway, which provides easy access to downtown Sarasota and the beaches on Siesta Key.

Bay Island is also close to many of Sarasota's popular cultural attractions, including the Ringling Museum of Art and the Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall. It's a highly sought after location for those looking to enjoy the Florida coastal lifestyle.

Bay Island currently has 29 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $5,484,000 and 6 lots for sale with an average list price of $5,329,983.33. The average annual property tax for Bay Island is $20,064.84.

Current Homes for Sale

Schools

View schools in Bay Island

What's Hot & What Not

Absorption Report Using the absorption rate, we can determine how long it's taking for homes to sell and which price points are selling the fastest in Bay Island, i.e. what's hot and what's not.

See What's Hot & What's Not in Bay Island

Recent Sales

View recent sales in Bay Island

Subdivisions

Subdivisions Median Price
No Photos

Bay Island

Bay Island is a single-family home community in Sarasota, Florida, built between 1925 and 2027. It currently has 10 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $6,495,700 and 3 lots for sale with an average list price of $6,126,633.33. The homes range in size from 1,202 ft2 to 8,138 ft2. The average annual property tax for Bay Island is $21,895.41. It is located in Sarasota County. ... Read more
Median Price: $1,300,000
No Photos

Bay Island Park

Bay Island Park is a single-family home community in the Bay Island neighborhood of Sarasota, Florida, built between 1953 and 1984. It currently has 3 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $1,807,666.67. The homes range in size from 1,446 ft2 to 3,064 ft2. The average annual property tax for Bay Island Park is $11,914.63. It is located in Sarasota County. ... Read more
Median Price: $775,000
No Photos

Bay Island Shores

Bay Island Shores is a single-family home community in the Bay Island neighborhood of Sarasota, Florida, built between 1951 and 2026. It currently has 3 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $4,590,000 and 1 lot for sale with a list price of $3,750,000. The homes range in size from 2,837 ft2 to 7,636 ft2. The HOA fees range from $4 to $4 per month. The average annual property tax for Bay Island Shores is $29,103.56. It is located in Sarasota County. ... Read more
Median Price: $3,000,000
No Photos

Lands End

Lands End is a single-family home community in the Bay Island neighborhood of Sarasota, Florida, built in 1967. It currently has no homes for sale. The homes have an average size of 2,743 ft2. The average annual property tax for Lands End is $7,771.85. It is located in Sarasota County. ... Read more

Subdivisions

View subdivisions in Bay Island

Market Trends

View market trends in Bay Island

Real Estate News

New Homes with In-ground Swimming Pools in Bay Island: April 12th to April 18th

New Homes with In-ground Swimming Pools in Bay Island: April 12th to April 18th - April 19, 2026

Bay Island had new homes for sale with an in-ground swimming pool during the month of Sunday, April 12 to Saturday, April 18, including 2 single family homes for ... continue reading
New Homes For Sale This Week in Bay Island: April 10th to April 16th

New Homes For Sale This Week in Bay Island: April 10th to April 16th - April 17, 2026

Bay Island had only 1 new home for sale during the week of Friday, April 10 to Thursday, April 16, including and it was a single family home for sale ... continue reading
New Construction Homes For Sale This Week in Bay Island: April 8th to April 14th

New Construction Homes For Sale This Week in Bay Island: April 8th to April 14th - April 15, 2026

Bay Island had only 1 new construction home during the week of Wednesday, April 8 to Tuesday, April 14, and it was a single family home for sale with a ... continue reading
Homes Just Sold in Bay Island: April 7th to April 13th

Homes Just Sold in Bay Island: April 7th to April 13th - April 14, 2026

Bay Island had only 1 sale during the week of Tuesday, April 7 to Monday, April 13, including and it was a single family home for sale with a list ... continue reading
New Homes with In-ground Swimming Pools in Bay Island: April 5th to April 11th

New Homes with In-ground Swimming Pools in Bay Island: April 5th to April 11th - April 12, 2026

Bay Island had only new homes for sale with an in-ground swimming pool during the month of Sunday, April 5 to Saturday, April 11, and it was a single ... continue reading
View More Bay Island News

Real Estate News

View Bay Island News

Sold Homes

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.