Bay Island, Sarasota, FL Real Estate

Bay Island is a residential enclave on a peninsula in southern Sarasota, bordered by Sarasota Bay to the west and Roberts Bay to the east. Residents reach St. Armands Circle and downtown Sarasota in roughly ten minutes by car and can access multiple waterfront parks and boat ramps within the neighborhood. The area is served by Phillippi Shores Elementary, Brookside Middle, and Riverview High schools, all rated above the state average.

Location
City Sarasota
State Florida
Averages
Taxes $22,475
House $6,925,765
Townhouse –
Condo –

Homes for Sale

Bay Island currently has 17 single family homes for sale and 5 lots for sale. There is 1 foreclosure for sale. For anyone looking for a brand new home, there are 10 new construction homes for sale.

Want to know the moment a new home goes up for sale in Bay Island?  Get Notified
Homes 17 for sale $750,000–$22,000,000
Condos 0 for sale
Townhouses 0 for sale
Multi-unit 1 for sale $599,900
Lots/Land 5 for sale $979,900–$6,700,000
Manufactured 0 for sale
Short Sales 0 for sale
Foreclosures 1 for sale $599,900
New Construction 10 for sale $1,475,000–$22,000,000
Brandon Caputo
Brandon Caputo
Real Estate Agent

Have questions? Looking to buy or sell? (888) 326-2726

Email Me

Schools

Sarasota County School District Elementary, Middle, High School
Elementary Phillippi Shores Elementary School Grades PK, KG-5
Middle Brookside Middle School Grades 6-8 Sarasota Middle School Grades 6-8
High School Sarasota High School Grades 9-12

Schools

View schools in Bay Island

Housing Report

Housing Market Report

Check out the hottest and the coldest price ranges in Bay Island.

Active Adult

Active 55+ Communities

Live your life fully in a Bay Island community built for adults 55 and older.

Compare Cities

Compare Neighborhoods

See how prices, $/ft2, and taxes in Bay Island stack up to other neighborhoods.

Subdivisions

Bay Island has 3 subdivisions offering single family homes. Prices range from $1,329,000 to $3,950,000. 1 subdivision offers new construction homes.

Browse All
3
Subdivisions in Bay Island
View all Subdivisions
Starter Homes
Bay Island Park
From $1,329,000
Luxury
Bay Island Shores
Up to $3,950,000
Single Family
3
Subdivisions with houses for sale
Browse Subdivisions
Townhouses
0
Subdivisions with townhouses for sale
Browse Subdivisions
Condos
0
Subdivisions with condos for sale
Browse Subdivisions
New Construction
1
Subdivisions with new construction listings
Browse Subdivisions

Subdivisions

View subdivisions in Bay Island

Market Trends

View market trends in Bay Island

Real Estate News

View Bay Island News

Sold Homes

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.