Bay Island Shores, Bay Island, Sarasota, FL, Real Estate

Get Notifications

Bay Island Shores is a single-family home and land community in the Bay Island neighborhood of Sarasota, Florida, built between 1951 and 2026. It currently has 2 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $3,250,000 and 1 lot for sale with a list price of $3,695,000. The homes range in size from 2,837 ft2 to 7,636 ft2. The HOA fee is $4 per month. The average annual property tax for Bay Island Shores is $29,034.99. It is located in Sarasota County.

Cats Allowed Dock Dogs Allowed Fishing Gulf Access Park Sidewalks Street Lights Water Access Waterfront

Location

Neighborhood Bay Island

City Sarasota

County Sarasota

State Florida

Averages

Taxes $29,035

House $3,250,000

Townhouse –

Condo –

Homes for Sale

894 Freeling Dr.

847 Freeling Dr.

View All Homes For Sale

Homes for Sale

View all homes for sale

Recent Sales

878 Freeling Dr.

749 Freeling Dr.

View All Recent Sales

Recent Sales

View recent sales in Bay Island Shores

Schools

Sarasota County School District Elementary, Middle, High School

Elementary Phillippi Shores Elementary School Grades PK, KG-5

Middle Brookside Middle School Grades 6-8

High School Sarasota High School Grades 9-12

Schools

View schools for Bay Island Shores

Market Trends

Median Sale Price Sales Volume

Market Trends

View market trends for Bay Island Shores

Similar Subdivisions in Sarasota

There are 34 other subdivisions in Sarasota with a similar median price within 20% of $3,000,000.

The Savoy on Palm

Median: $3,000,000

Median: $3,000,000

Median: $2,995,000

Peninsula Sarasota

Median: $2,965,768

Median: $3,050,000

Heron Lagoon Lodges

Median: $3,050,000

Paradise Shores

Median: $2,875,000

Royal Palm Harbor

Median: $2,850,000

Siestas Bayside Waterside Wood

Median: $3,180,000

Median: $2,800,000

Median: $2,800,000

Median: $2,800,000

Median: $3,270,000

Median: $2,700,000

Median: $2,687,500

Kingfisher Estates at Waterside

Median: $3,315,000

Median: $2,675,000

The Tower Residences

Median: $2,650,000

Red Rock Terrace

Median: $2,640,000

Median: $2,597,500

Median: $2,550,000

Secluded Harbour

Median: $2,550,000

Sarasota Ranch Club

Median: $2,537,500

Park Residences

Median: $2,525,000

Riegels Landing

Median: $3,500,000

Hudson Crossing

Median: $2,500,000

Median: $3,500,000

Forest at the Hi Hat Ranch

Median: $2,462,500

Median: $2,450,000

Median: $2,450,000

Median: $2,437,500

Wild Blue at Waterside

Median: $2,427,317.50

Median: $2,410,000

Crescent Towers

Median: $3,595,000

Show All 34 Subdivisions

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.