Banyan Bay, Fort Myers, FL, Real Estate

Get Notifications

Banyan Bay is a single-family home community in Fort Myers, Florida, built between 2007 and 2026. It currently has 7 single family homes for sale with an average list price of $446,128.57. The homes range in size from 1,703 ft2 to 4,485 ft2. The HOA fees range from $233 to $267 per month. The average annual property tax for Banyan Bay is $4,493.58. It is located in Lee County.

Banyan Bay is a gated community that embodies relaxed Florida living, surrounded by three picturesque lakes and expansive conservation areas offering stunning views of natural preserves and abundant wildlife. Residents delight in a resort-style atmosphere with amenities designed for leisure and connection, including a sparkling community pool and inviting cabana perfect for lounging or poolside gatherings, a state-of-the-art fitness center for wellness routines, meandering walking trails for scenic strolls, and thoughtfully landscaped grounds that enhance the tranquil vibe. Family-friendly touches abound, such as a playground for children and picnic areas for casual barbecues, all within a secure, pet-welcoming enclave that provides easy access to nearby beaches, shopping, and dining while fostering a sense of peaceful seclusion.

Bike Storage Cats Allowed Clubhouse Dogs Allowed Gated Park Picnic Area Playground Pool (Community) Shopping Sidewalks Spa/Hot Tub Street Lights Trail(s) Waterfront

Location

City Fort Myers

County Lee

State Florida

Averages

Taxes $4,494

House $446,129

Townhouse –

Condo –

Homes for Sale

8641 Banyan Bay Blvd.

8681 Banyan Bay Blvd.

8554 Banyan Bay Blvd.

8618 Banyan Bay Blvd.

View All Homes For Sale

Homes for Sale

View all homes for sale

Recent Sales

8724 Banyan Bay Blvd.

8558 Banyan Bay Blvd.

8613 Banyan Bay Blvd.

8108 Banyan Breeze Way

View All Recent Sales

Recent Sales

View recent sales in Banyan Bay

Schools

Lee School District Elementary

Elementary Rayma C. Page Elementary School Grades PK, KG-6

Schools

View schools for Banyan Bay

Market Trends

Median Sale Price Sales Volume

Market Trends

View market trends for Banyan Bay

Nearby Golf Courses

Crown Colony Golf & Country Club

Crown Colony Golf & Country Club

8851 Crown Colony Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908
18 holes • Par 72 • 7013 yards

Lexington Country Club

Lexington Country Club

16257 Willowcrest Way, Fort Myers, FL 33908
18 holes • Par 72 • 7123 yards

The Forest Country Club

The Forest Country Club

6100 Club Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908

Nearby Golf Courses

View golf courses near Banyan Bay

Similar Subdivisions in Fort Myers

There are 204 other subdivisions in Fort Myers with a similar median price within 20% of $471,500.

Buckingham Park South

Median: $472,500

Median: $470,000

Venetian Pointe

Median: $470,000

Arborwood Preserve

Median: $470,000

Median: $475,000

Longboat Village

Median: $475,000

San Carlos Park North Addition

Median: $475,000

Seminole Estates

Median: $475,000

Median: $475,000

Median: $467,500

Colonial Shores

Median: $467,500

Heritage Preserve

Median: $467,000

Caloosa Yacht and Racquet Club

Median: $466,000

Daniels Preserve

Median: $464,700

Median: $479,000

Median: $480,000

Timberwood Preserve

Median: $480,000

Median: $480,000

Riverside Avenue Villas

Median: $482,000

Median: $460,000

Clipper Cove Village

Median: $460,000

Cottages at Gateway Greens

Median: $460,000

Harbor Place Vistas

Median: $460,000

Median: $460,000

Riviera Terrace

Median: $484,500

Schooner Village

Median: $458,225

Orangetree Bend

Median: $458,000

Median: $485,000

Median: $485,250

Median: $486,250

Bridgetown at the Plantation

Median: $487,500

Median: $487,500

Florimond Manor

Median: $455,000

Median: $455,000

Median: $455,000

Median: $488,000

Median: $455,000

Median: $453,750

Median: $492,000

Median: $450,000

The Lakes at Three Oaks

Median: $450,000

Median: $450,000

Pine Run at Three Oaks

Median: $450,000

Median: $450,000

The Villas at Causeway Key

Median: $450,000

Median: $450,000

Median: $449,999.50

Median: $493,500

Eagle Lake Estates

Median: $495,000

Median: $495,000

Median: $495,000

Prato at Pelican Preserve

Median: $495,000

Median: $495,000

Median: $445,000

Median: $445,000

Harts Truck Farms

Median: $445,000

Plantation Pines Subd

Median: $499,000

Median: $499,500

Median: $499,900

Median: $500,000

Cox J B 2nd Subd

Median: $500,000

Median: $500,000

Cypress Preserve at Colonial

Median: $500,000

Median: $500,333

Median: $500,500

Trieste at Pelican Preserve

Median: $442,500

Valencia Harbor

Median: $501,900

Median: $440,250

Median: $440,000

Ireland + King Subd

Median: $440,000

Median: $440,000

River Grove Estates

Median: $440,000

Median: $439,000

Median: $438,700

Reflection Isles

Median: $505,000

Median: $437,500

Median: $437,500

Median: $506,000

Portofino at Pelican Preserve

Median: $436,250

Median: $435,750

Callaway Greens

Median: $435,000

Cypress Garden View

Median: $435,000

Gladiolus Preserve

Median: $435,000

Median: $435,000

Twin Palm Estates

Median: $435,000

Avalon Preserve

Median: $510,000

Median: $510,000

Median: $433,000

Median: $432,828

Woodgate Estates

Median: $432,500

Parkway Preserve

Median: $432,110

Cross Creek Estates

Median: $432,000

Pine Glen at Three Oaks

Median: $511,000

Casella at Pelican Preserve

Median: $511,500

Viadana at Pelican Preserve

Median: $430,250

Median: $430,000

Median: $430,000

Median: $514,000

Median: $429,000

Cottage Point Subd

Median: $514,500

Median: $427,500

McGregor Gardens

Median: $426,000

Cypress Chase at Three Oaks

Median: $425,000

Heritage Cove II

Median: $425,000

Median: $425,000

Plantation Preserve

Median: $425,000

Median: $425,000

Median: $425,000

Median: $425,000

Median: $519,000

Median: $520,000

Majestic Pointe

Median: $422,500

Timberlake at Three Oaks

Median: $422,500

Materita at Pelican Preserve

Median: $420,000

Median: $420,000

Verandas at Twin Lakes

Median: $420,000

Median: $419,000

Median: $418,750

Beachwalk Isles

Median: $525,000

Median: $525,000

Median: $525,000

The Reserve at Estero

Median: $525,000

Median: $525,000

Villas at Pineview

Median: $525,000

Median: $417,500

Median: $417,500

Median: $416,000

Median: $415,000

Orange River Hills

Median: $415,000

Waters Edge at The Forest

Median: $414,500

Ten Mile Anchorage

Median: $412,500

Toscana at Pelican Preserve

Median: $412,500

Coves of Estero Bay

Median: $410,000

Median: $410,000

Verandas at Royal Greens

Median: $409,750

Heritage Cove I

Median: $409,000

Avila at Pelican Preserve

Median: $407,500

Happy Bull Farms

Median: $405,000

Villas at Olde Hickory

Median: $405,000

Waterford Village

Median: $405,000

Pratts Preserve

Median: $405,000

Median: $404,000

Tiberio at Pelican Preserve

Median: $540,000

Median: $541,000

Median: $542,000

Median: $400,500

Lazy Acres Ranchettes

Median: $542,500

Median: $542,500

Coyle Subdivision

Median: $400,000

Estero Preserve

Median: $400,000

Median: $400,000

Paradise Shores

Median: $400,000

Median: $400,000

Median: $399,999

Median: $399,900

Median: $543,250

Median: $544,750

Becklers Riverside

Median: $398,000

The Islands at Three Oaks

Median: $398,000

Median: $545,000

Heron Coach Houses

Median: $396,500

Southwind Subdivision

Median: $547,500

Bellavista at Gulf Harbour

Median: $547,505

Median: $395,000

Verandas at Fairway Isle

Median: $395,000

Median: $550,000

Median: $550,000

Median: $550,000

Median: $550,000

Median: $550,000

Median: $392,500

Median: $392,500

Whiskey Creek Terrace

Median: $392,500

Median: $392,000

Mission Monterey

Median: $390,000

Median: $390,000

Buckingham Park

Median: $389,950

Median: $554,000

Median: $555,000

Colonial Pointe

Median: $555,000

Cypress Preserve

Median: $555,000

Median: $555,000

Harbour Isle Estates

Median: $555,000

Median: $387,500

Median: $386,250

Median: $557,500

Prentiss Pointe

Median: $385,000

Median: $384,950

Bell Tower Park

Median: $383,000

Median: $560,000

Median: $560,000

Median: $381,000

Median: $562,500

Engleside Lanes

Median: $380,000

Glen Abbey at Fiddlesticks

Median: $380,000

Median: $380,000

Median: $380,000

Median: $380,000

Verandas at McArthur

Median: $380,000

Swan Lake South

Median: $379,900

San Carlos Park Golf Course Addition

Median: $379,500

Median: $565,000

Median: $565,000

Valentina at Pelican Preserve

Median: $565,000

Show All 204 Subdivisions

We have helped thousands of families buy and sell homes!

HomesByMarco agents are experts in the area. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, give us a call today at 888-326-2726.